Monday, 17 November 2008

Panthic.org and Bhasauria

http://www.panthic.org/news/135/ARTICLE/3120/2007-02-21.html

Could it not be that the people behind Panthic.org are followers of Bhasauria after this post?
Singh Sabha Bhasaur
Wednesday 21st of February 2007
Dr. Harbans Singh
The Singh Sabha crusade for enlightenment reached its culminating point in a huge Sikh convention held on June 14, 1903, at the village of Bakapur, in Jullundur district. The occasion marked the conversion to Sikhism of Karim Bakhsh, born Muslim, and his family of 4 sons and a daughter. Some Hindus of that village as well as Sikhs from among the audience were also initiated on that day. The ceremony was marked by considerable fanfare. The sponsors were the Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Bhasaur, which, under the leadership of Babu Teja Singh (1867-1933), then a sub-overseer in the Irrigation Department of Patiala state, was very active in purifying Sikh ritual and re-establishing its autonomy.
The Bhasaur Singh Sabha, located in a little village, in Patiala state, was among the more energetic of the Singh Sabhas in those days. The dynamite came from the personality of its secretary, Babu Teja Singh. He possessed a fertile mind and was an untiring campaigner. By his stern resoluteness and limitless capacity for innovation, he brought to the Singh Sabha renaissance a new verve and thrust. He was a puritan of the extremist kind, and a fundamentalist in the interpretation of Sikh principles and tradition. He challenged much of the prevalent Sikh usage.
The Singh Sabha in the village of Bhasaur was established in 1893. This was 20 years after the first Singh Sabha came into existence in Amritsar. Bhai Basawa Singh, known as 'virakt' or recluse, was the first president of the Bhasaur Singh Sabha and Babu Teja Singh was its first secretary. The Bhasaur Singh Sabha was, from the very beginning, forthright in the rejection of caste and Brahmanical customs which had infiltrated into Sikhism. It openly advocated the acceptance back into the Sikh fold of those who had been led into forsaking their faith. It went further and willingly converted members of other faiths who volunteered for initiation.
A Shuddi Sabha had been established by Dr Jai Singh in Lahore on April 17, 1893, with the object of "reclaiming those Sikhs and Hindus who had apostatized themselves by contracting alliances with Muslim men or women." The Bhasaur Singh Sabha was critical of the limited objective of the Shuddi Sabha and questioned its very designation which, it said, was only an imitation of Aarya Samaj vocabulary. From its very inception, it had accepted for conversion Muslims and those from lower Hindu castes. As the records say, at the first annual divan of the Bhausaur Singh Sabha held in 1894, 13 'Jats' 6 'Jhivars' (water-carriers), 2 'barbers', 1 'Khatri' and 1 Musalman (Miran Bakhsh, of Tahsil Garshankar, who became Nihal Singh) were initiated into the Sikh faith. Babu Teja Singh himself published in the press a report of a subsequent year saying: "By the power of the word revealed by the ten masters and in accord with Akalpurakh's wish, the Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Bhasaur, has administered the Gurumantra and holy amrit to a Muslim woman and ushered her into Sodhbans (the family of Guru Gobind Singh). Her Sikh name is Krishan Kaur. A Sikh who had fallen by living with a Muslim woman has been baptized and renamed Ude Singh."
Karim Bakhsh was born of Muslim parents, Nathu and Barsi, at Bakapur, in 1860. He was of a religious turn of mind. This disturbed his family, who, to detract him from his lonely ways, married him when he was barely 12. At the age of 15 Karim Bakhsh's quest for spiritual company took him to a Sikh Saint, Bhai Kahla Singh, of Banga at whose feet he spent 2 years. After Bhai Kahla Singh's death, Karim Bakhsh sought solace in the service of his disciple, Bhai Dula Singh of Thakurwal. For 12 years, he presented himself once every week in the holy sangat at Thakurwal, 32 kilometers away from his village.
Karim Bakhsh spent most of his time reciting Gurbani from memory. He used to welcome the Sikhs with the Khalsa greeting and made regular visits to Amritsar to bathe in the sacred pool. He suffered ostracism and insult at the hands of his coreligionists. Gradually, his wife was also converted to his way of life and, as the report says, he established conjugal relations with her only after he was convinced of her faith in Sikhism.
The story of the Bakapur family reached Bhasaur through Bhai Takht Singh of Ferozepore, pioneer of women's education among Sikhs. This was corroborated by some other members of the Singh Sabha who supplied further details of Karim Bakhsh's interest in Sikhism. The Bhasaur Sabha decided to make its own investigations. Kahla Singh, who made a secret visit to Bakapur, confirmed the story. This led the Sabha to offer to convert the Bakapur family at its annual divan of 1901, but it had to give up the plan owing to the outbreak of plague in the country. In 1902, Maulavi Karim Bakhsh attended the large annual divan of the Sikhs at Bhasaur, but returned empty-handed owing to a controversy that had arisen among them.
The Bhasaur Singh Sabha sent its emissaries - Bhai Teja Singh of Maingan, Sardar Bishan Singh and Bhai Takht Singh - to visit Bakapur by turns and assure Karim Bakhsh that his heart's wish must be fulfilled. Finally, Babu Teja Singh went himself. At Bakapur, he learnt that Maulavi Karim Bakhsh's wife had passed away less than a week earlier and that the last rites had been performed strictly in accordance with the Sikh injunctions. There was the Guru Granth Sahib Ji kept with true reverence in a room in the house and the Sikh kirtan was performed daily.
On return, Babu Teja Singh issued a public notice signifying that a big divan of the Khalsa would be convened in the village of Bakapur on June 13-14, 1903. The letter was sent on behalf of the Bhasaur Singh Sabha to all the leading Sikh societies and individuals inviting them to participate in the proceedings. The letter included a note on the Bakapur family and its zeal for the Sikh faith.
The invitation widely circulated evoked a ready response. On the appointed day, batches of Sikhs converged on Bakapur from places such as Lahore, Amritsar, Gujranwala, Gujjarkhan, Katani, Narangwal and Ludhiana. An elderly uncle of Sardar Sundar Singh Majithia, Baba Hira Singh, led a jatha from the Amritsar Khalsa College. The group included Bhai Jodh Singh (distinguished Sikh theologian and educationist of modern times), who was then a student of the final B.A. class, Tara Singh, who had just joined college and who later became famous as a political leader, and Man Singh, who rose to be the president of the Judicial Committee in Faridkot state.
On the morning of the opening day of the proceedings, Maulavi Karim Bakhsh rose at 2 in the morning, performed his ablutions and came to the site of the divan. He sat in a room rapt in meditation. The Asa-ki-Var was sung after which different jathas took turns at kirtan. They included the Singh Sabha of Gujjarwal, Sardar Basant Singh [Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh] and Munshi Anup Singh of Narangwal and the Youth Leage of Ludhiana. For a while, a group of women also led the kirtan. Chanting of the sacred shabad went on until it was time for Guru-ka-Langar or community meal. The afternoon divan was addressed by Babu Teja Singh, who explained the purpose of the convention and sought from the audience names of those who would wish to be baptized. First to volunteer was Basant Singh, a former Panjab University student, of the village of Narangwal, in Ludhiana district, who, after initiation, was named Randhir Singh and who became known as a revolutionary and, later, as a saintly personage of much sanctity among the Sikhs.
To conduct the initiation ceremonies the following day, the five Piare designated were Bhai Teja Singh of Rawalpindi, Takht Singh, Zinda Shahid (Living Martyr), of Ferozepur, Bhai Basant Singh of Bappiana (Patiala state), Bhai Sohan Singh of Gujjarkhan and Bhai Amar Singh of Raja Ghuman,. Bhai Jodh Singh was named granthi for the ceremonies.
In all, 35 persons received the Sikh baptism the following morning (June 14). Maulavi Karim Bakhsh, 43, was named Lakhbir Singh after initiation. His 4 sons Rukan Din, 15, Fateh Din, 12, Ghulam Muhammed, 6, and Khair Din, 4, became Matab Singh, Kirpal Singh, Harnam Singh and Gurbakhsh Singh, respectively. His daughter Bibi Nuran, 9, was given the Sikh name of Waryam Kaur. Lakhbir Singh won wide esteem in the Sikh community as Sant (saint) Lakhbir Singh. He migrated to Amritsar, where his daily routine began with a visit to the Golden Temple. He would reach there soon after midnight, before the doors of the Harimandir were opened, and recite the Sukhmani while circumambulating the shrine. His holiness was commonly acknowledged and he counted among his admirers men like Bhai Vir Singh and Sundar Singh Majithia (1872-1941). H is son, Matab Singh, founded a society called Khalsa Baradari and played a pioneer role in the campaign for the reformation of the Sikh sacred places. Matab Singh's son, Gurcharan Singh Sakhi, took his Bachelor's degree at the Khalsa College at Amritsar, and edited, among others, a Sikh religious journal until he died suddenly in the Golden Temple ambulatory in 1973.
The Bakapur divan marked a high point in the Singh Sabha resurgence. It was a visible expression of the new urges which moved the Sikh community at that time. A sweeping religious fervour, a new sense of identity and unity and a decisive breach with the recent past dominated by customs and practices which had no sanction in the tradition were the characteristics of contemporary Sikhism. These dramatically highlighted at Bakapur.
Singh Sabhas were now springing up in all parts of the Punjab, those at Amritsar, Lahore, Rawalpindi, Jullundur, Ludhiana, Ferozepur, Patiala, Nabha, Faridkot, Bagrian, Bhasaur, Kapurthala, and Simla being notably active. To coordinate the work of the Amritsar Singh Sabha and the Lahore Singh Sabha, established by Bhai Gurmukh Singh in 1877, a joint board called the General Sabha was formed. The General Sabha was subsequently replaced by the Khalsa Diwan which was set up at Amritsar in 1883. The lieutenant-Governor of the Punjab and Raja Bikram Singh of Faridkot were its Patrons. Baba Khem Singh was made president and Bhai Gurmukh Singh chief secretary. This Khalsa Diwan became the affiliating centre for all the Singh Sabhas. But owing to differences between Amritsar Singh Sabha and Lahore Singh Sabha brought to a head by the style in which the Amritsar leader, Baba Khem Singh, was apotheosized by his followers, a schism occurred. Bhai Gurmukh Singh and his colleagues established a separate Khalsa Diwan at Lahore in 1886.(Extract from 'Heritage of the Sikhs' by Dr Harbans Singh)

Danger of the Bhasauria mindset

From an unknown person on Sikh Sangat.com
Now that i have got your attention, most people when they read bhusaria they automatically assume bhusaria is refferred to teja singh bhusaria who was excommunciated from the panth by attempting to take bhagata di bani out of sri guru granth sahib ji. Sangat would ask why i am mentioning his name, he was excommunciated, he passed away, case closed. But if case was closed that easily, there wouldnt be major internal ideaological differences in the panth to begin with. This post will shed some light how bhausaria mindset is still alive and eating panth from inside even though bhausaria physical body is not alive.

When teja singh bhausaria some close to 100 years ago came in the panth, he bought fwd loads of outrageous claims, bold statements without any proof, far most serious all- he created sense of confusion among sangat, this sense of sansa(doubts) replicated day by day, now after 100 years his claims/statements somehow form into an beleif system itself which many sikhs some openly/some in gupt form adhere to. The sense of confusion of issue he created in the panth still exist to this day.Here are some of claims/statements of teja singh bhausaria, they still exist today in form of beleif system not as statement but subtly residing in beleif system.

This is taken from sant gurbachan singh ji bhindranwale work- Gurmat Rehit Maryada- orginal work look below:

1. There is no such thing as santhood in sikhi, this has became a very very common beleif in sikh mainstream circle, it all started from bhausaria, he started by totally taking out 13th ashtpadi from sukhmani sahib in his soo called reform sri guru granth sahib, new age sikh brothers who adhered to above beleif system do this by making bold statements like sant shabad in sri guru granth sahib ji only refers to guru sahib only and thats it without doing any actual vichar, when they debate how sants are evil and stuff most of them forget about sukhmani sahib. This is very interesting parallelism between bhausaria beleif when he was alive and bhausaria mindset which crept into beleif system which many sikhs adhere to this day.

2. Sri Ram Chandar and Sri Krishan ji Upma/Ustat(glory) had no place in gurbani/sikhi, bhausaria feeling was soo soo insecure that he actually to prove his claim, he started replacing ram with Wah and Har with Gur in Savaie Bhatt gurbani, also he took out ram/krishan and other hindu devi's/devta's in his so called reform version of sri guru granth sahib ji. New Age sikh brothers who adhered to above beleif system also do the same deed via slightly different manner which is by creating an very distrubing hindu paranioa and extreme insecurity. This is also very interesting parellelism between bhausaria beleif and bhausaria mindset which exist today, fine i acknowledge bhasuaria mindset which exist today dont have power or guts even touch sri guru granth sahib to modify what their predeccessors did but imagine in next decade if bhausaria mindset gets in the majority and start controlling panth decisions- what will they do???. Although i think this whole distrubing hindu parniao and exterme insecurity have diseased many sikhs in the panthic circle already.

3. Bhausaria orginally claimed that in ardas instead of pritham bhaguti simarkae, there should be satnam simar kai, this beleif crept again in the bhausaria mindset adapted now, it shows nothing but insecurity that if we start saying pritham bhaguti simar kai which is taken from sri chandi di var, sikhs will start beleiving in sri dasam granth sahib. Therefore lets subtly question each and every slight tradition of khalsa, ardas to naam simran so that sikhs start questioning its own tradition and start having more doubts in sri dasam granth sahib ji. This is exactly what bhausaria mindset ie- new age sikhi groups ie- kala afghana followers, missionary groups does. Sometimes they question ardas indirectly pointing towards authencity of sri dasam granth sahib, sometimes they question concept of reincarnation/heaven/hell concepts just because this universal concepts were shared by hindu dharam, again nothing but extreme insecurity shared by both- bhausaria beleif as an person and bausaria mindset which crept into beleif system which many sikhs adhere to this day.
4. Bhausaria claimed sataie balvandaie vaar is not part of gurbani, this claim crept into sikhi and was later supported by prof sahib singh who many sikhs beleive an one and only authority to translate/interpret sri guru granth sahib ji punjabi.




Wake up people, real enemy of beautiful khalsa panth adorned by sri guru gobind singh ji is not RSS(they are very easy to refute, nirmala samparda have refuted them many many times in the past), real enemy is dangerous Bhausaria mindset exist still today, real enemy is not a human being or set of people or organization but dangerous bhausaria mindset. Human being or set of people or organization cannot be real cause of panth setbacks, classic example- back in the time some people may have thought while teja singh bhausaria time that the real dushman is bhausaria, when he leaves the earth all claims/bold statements/ actions he took will be vanished but look what happened now? All the bhausarias beleif's have subtly crept into beleif system many sikhs adhere to now. So real enemy is that mindset not any personality, group of people. Only way to get rid of it, is by parchar which should politely target this bhasuaria mindset which has deep rooted in many praticing sikhs today.thats all for now.


Taken from SikhSangat.com


The Living Guru

Das presented a paper on the Guru Granth Sahib at leicester:


New Walk Museum Talk: The Living Guru (part 1)
Tuesday 14th October, 12.30pm – 1.30pm

Introduction to the exhibition, ‘The Living Guru – The Holy Sikh Scripture’, with Kamalroop Singh, specialist on Sikh religion, PhD candidate, University of Birmingham.

Here are some of the slides from the talk:

The above photo is a recension of Adi Guru Granth Sahib given to Pir Buddhu Shah after his five sons, all died for the Panth. The Muslim marytrs of the Panth are known as Mureeds. Guru Ji never asked them to convert. This recension contains raga mala. Circa 1690's.


A beautiful recension of Guru Ji, in the Sikh reference library Sri Darbar Sahib, Amritsar. It also contains the raga mala, and has a colophon of 1777 A.D.


The above photograph is of the beginning of Guru Maharaj, this recension was written in Baba Deep Singhs Taksal, at Dam Dama Sahib and ends with raga mala. Circa 1720 A.D.


Changing Guru Granth Sahib and the Girls school.

Babu Teja Singh (1867-1933) was given a girls school by the authorities, the British, as he was a civil servant and loyalist of the British colonial Raj ( a sub-overseer in the Irrigation Department of Patiala State). Not only did he inspire the girls of this school to wear Keski's, Turbans, he also inspired them to write a new version of Guru Granth Sahib. See Prof. Sahib Singh's authobiography for the original in Gurmukhi.
Sahib Singh Ji once going to meet Ran Singh the son of Babu Teja Singh, found alot of the girls had ink on their hands. He asked them what they had been doing? They answered that they are writing the Hazuri Birh of Guru Granth Sahib. They took him into a room, and there were many papers and ink, and an attempt had been made to make the new writing look old.
On questioning Ran Singh, he replied that they wanted to create a new Guru Granth Sahib and bury it at Hazur Sahib and claim it was original to put the Sikh Panth at rest due to all the controversy at that time about Gurbani.
This involved adding in some writings of Guru Gobind Singh, and taking out Bhagat Bani, Rag Mala, Bhatta Di Svaiye, as well as changing that heading orders in bani. It was shortly after this Teja Singh was excommunicated from the Panth for life, along with his family and wife. This was "Babu Teja Singh's zealous efforts to prune Sikh doctrine and practice of Hindu icons".

See. Sociology of Diaspora: A Reader, by Ajaya Kumar Sahoo, Brij Maharaj, 2007 - p. 666
To make matters worse many girls were sexually abused. For example every summer there would be requests by the Maharah of Patiala to shift the girls near his summer house.
See. Praja Mandal Movement in East Punjab States - p. 21, by Ramesh Walia.
There are also three recorded accounts of the sexual abuse that took place at Panch Khand, by three former students of the Girls school. These will be added to this blog at a later date.
In conclusion Bhai Randhir Singhs association and intiation into the Panth by the heretic, British loyalist, and potential sex abuser Babu Teja Singh, adds little credibility to the authenticity of the neo-maryada of the AKJ.

Bhai Randhir Singh and his relationship with the heretic Babu Teja Singh

Bhai Randhir Singh, records his relationship with Babu Teja Singh, in his autobiography, the Jail letters.
He records the meeting with the Panch Khand in 1908-09. How he was part of laying the foundation stone of the Panch Khand, and spent time there in Gurmat gatherings. Jail Letters, p. 58. He narrates how much bliss he experienced there, that has never left him. This shows clearly his close affliation with Panch Khand, and in particular Teja Singh Bhasauria.
We have already stated that the AKJ reintiates people with Amrit, with their own version of Amrit. The roots of this can be found in the Jail letters. Bhai Randhir Singh was not satisfied in taking amrit once, he took it again. The second time the Singh narrated the rahit or Khalsa code to him, was non other than Babu Teja Singh himself. Most Sikhs consider Babu Teja Singh to be a heretic, and a British loyalist, bent on destroying traditional Sikh praxis, and exegesis. Jail letters. p.28. Here we can see how the practices of the AKJ have its roots in the Panch Khalsa Diwan, and the writings of Babu Teja Singh.
Before his imprisonment, he was an intimate friend of Babu Teja Singh of Bhasaur and was also instrumental in establishing Panch Khalsa Diwan at Bhasaur in association with him. Babu Teja Singh was then quite a dynamic personality amongst the Sikhs and was a leading figure in the Singh Sabha resurgence. The Panthic Conference, where Bhai Sahib had taken Amrit along with Maulvi Karim Baksh and his family, was also organized by Babu Teja Singh. Hence both of them had become close friends. However, as Babu Teja Singh became a British Government loyalist, Bhai Sahib stopped working in association with him. During the period of Bhai Sahib's internment, Babu Teja Singh had been excommunicated from the Panth.
Meeting with Babu Teja Singh
After Bhai Sahib's release, Babu Teja Singh tried to meet his old friend after twenty years and came to his house to resurrect their old friendship. Bhai Sahib was not there at that moment. When he came to know later of Babu Ji's visit, Bhai Sahib wrote him a letter politely declining to meet him. The contents of the letter are very moving and reveal the true personality of Bhai Sahib and his unshakable and abiding faith in the Sikh tenets, values and traditions. It is therefore considered worthwhile to reproduce the English translation of the same below:
"Babu Teja Singh ji, Waheguru ji ki Fateh. You, dear Sir, have come to see this humble servant of the Panth after one fifth of a century, i.e., 20 years. I was no less eager to have the chance of meeting with you and talking together. But I was deeply pained when I learnt that you have been excommunicated from the Panth by a congregation at Sri Akal Takht.
What is even more distressing, you continue to disregard the authority of the Panth. It is now my request that you should be obedient to the Command of the Guru Panth and return to its shelter. Then we shall meet like brothers. It is my hope that you will accede to my request and thereby please the hearts of all of us. I am confident that you will not defy the Guru Panth and will abide by the tradition coming down through generations. Your sincere well wisher (s) Randhir Singh"
Thus, no personal relationship would deflect Bhai Sahib from obeying in letter and spirit the edicts of the Guru Panth issued from Sri Akal Takht Sahib.

The Muslim Rababi's

Guru Nanak's companion was Bhai Mardana, a Muslim. He was the first Rababi, literally bard or Rebeck player of the Panth. This tradition continued on in the times of Guru Hargobind Sahib, where many also became Dhadhi's. Into the times of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, then into the times of the Sikh Misals, all the way up to the Singh Sabha movement.
In Khalsa Rahit Prakas, Babu Teja Singh first insults the tradition of the Rababi's. He says " why are these filthy Muslims, who smoke, allowed to do Kirtan. It is against Gurmat they must take Amrit first". This kind of racism is common throughout this book. See British Library, Bhasaur, 1917, Panj D 549.
It was due to this racism that the tradition of stringed instruments, and kirtan in traditional ragas came to an end. To the improvised version found in the AKJ.
Rababi’s unfulfilled desire Rashmi Talwar

WITH an ardent desire and hope in his heart, Bhai Lalji, the 17th generation descendant of the family of Bhai Mardana, came to Amritsar from Pakistan, to perform kirtan at Sri Harmindar Sahib.
All his hopes were dashed when the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbhandak Committee (SGPC) refused him permission, upholding the ban imposed on non-Sikhs performing kirtan at the Golden Temple.
A visibly distraught Bhai Lal, a ‘rababi’ and Muslim by birth, in a special interaction with The Tribune said, “Even my old age does not allow me the comfort of the claim of having achieved all in my lifetime, as a fervent desire still remains with me of performing kirtan for the one last time at the Harmindar Sahib. The craving for blessing from Guru Ram Dass, the founder of the Golden Temple, after performing kirtan is the life’s only mission left unfulfilled”. The ‘rababi’ who performed kirtan for two hours at the Golden Temple for one last time in 1962 besides 14 kirtans at Akal Takht asks emotionally, “Will I go back once again to Pakistan with an unfulfilled dream?”
The ban was imposed soon after his last performance in 1962. Belonging to the generation of Bhai Mardana, a Muslim ‘rababi’ of the time, being nine years older than the first Sikh Guru Nanak Dev, he started accompanying the Guru. Then for 47 years at every forum that the Guru sojourned to, Bhai Mardana performed kirtan with him. So much so, many of the ‘banis’ of ‘rababis’ were incorporated in the Guru Granth Sahib.
In the footsteps of his forefathers, Bhai Lal too, is completely devoted to the traditional ‘parampara’ of kirtan. He can perhaps be counted amongst the few ‘kirtankaars’ of the world today who can sing kirtan using all 31 ragas without eyeing a paper. Sikh history and historical moments are on his fingertips.
Born in 1929 as Ashik Ali at Goindwal where his father was a “rababi” performing kirtan at Goindwal Sahib, Lal Singh learned the Gurmukhi (Punjabi) at a local primary school. Then he was sent to learn kirtan from Bhai Khisita at Amritsar at the age of 11 years in 1940. After two years of tutorship under him, Bhai Lal started kirtan under ‘rababi’ Bhai Chand; “Since then I came to be known as Bhai Lal and have been addressed so, ever since,” he recalls.
Thereby Partition led him to flee India, and he and his father settled in Lahore where he got married and fathered four sons. While his sons enjoy kirtan and accompany him somehow none of them have actually followed in their forefathers’ footsteps due tolack of patronage from Sikh institutions and Sikh bodies. “Two of my sons are electricians, while one polishes utensils and the youngest remains a free roamer despite having passed plus 2,” he says with regret.
On his last visit to India in 1999, Bhai Lal was honoured with 19 awards by various Sikh organisations. These included the honour conferred at Anandpur Sahib by the SGPC, one by the Delhi Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee another by Damdami Taksal, Patna Sahib, Hazoor Sahib and others.
Talking about Pakistan, he says, “Who is interested in kirtan in Pakistan?” and reveals that the chance to perform kirtan is only during the Indian jathas’ visit at Nankana Sahib, Panja Sahib and Dera Sahib Gurdwaras or occasionally when a Sindhi devout of the Guru, invites him for kirtan. Sindhis, he says are the only Pakistanis who thoroughly enjoy kirtan and hold it in great regard.
Meanwhile, in a fervert appeal to the SGPC on behalf of ‘rababis’ and Bhai Lal, the International Bhai Mardana Yaadgari Kirtan Darbar Society president Harpal Singh Bhullar says the SGPC going against the very tenets of Sikhism which follows the tradition of denouncing discrimination on all levels, including religion, caste and colour by disallowing ‘Rababi’ Bhai Lal to perform in the Golden Temple, while no ban exists on them in any other gurdwara in the world.
Below is a clip of Bhai Lal performing some amazing kirtan:


Now compare with this Kirtan:


http://www.gurmarag.net/SikhAwareness/Audio/akj%20simran.mp3

Ex-Criminals running the Panth

You may think that the local Sikh leader is spotless in character. Think again. Never let peoples soft speech and chrisma fool you.

There are some members of the Sangat that participate in the Panj Piaras in the UK who are convicted peodophiles, rapists, armed robbers, drug dealers, terrorists and so on.

In the next few weeks. On this blog they will be exposed.

If you are on a Gurudwara commitee please run CRB checks on people. Its the only way to be safe.

Sunday, 16 November 2008

The Khalsa - Adi Guru Granth sahib Ji - The Rag Mala

Three great Mahapurush and firm believers in the completeness of Gurbani. They made great sacrifices for the Panth.

http://fateh.sikhnet.com/sikhnet/articles.nsf/e6a281b4262b05de87256671004e06c5/d71e2814beebe51e87256671004e4636!OpenDocument

Today we are told we should not read Rag Mala. We can read 1429 pages, and one page will give us a stomach ache? It's my Guru. Whether he wears mala, mund mala, raag mala, dand mala, what do I care? Guru is Guru. I'm not subjecting myself whether my Guru, which mala my Guru wears. My Guru has worn a mala. It's inferior or superior, it's bad or good, it's none of my problem. But you do not understand, in this scheme there's a scheme in it. They want to create a doubt on the Guru in your mind and heart. They are telling you that your Guru is not true. They are telling you, "Guru granth jee maanio pargat guraa kee de," is wrong. That's what they are telling you. And I am telling you, "Gur kee nindaa sune na kaan, Sees bhet kare kirpaan." --Old Punjabi Saying(Literal translation: A Sikh can never tolerate slandering againstthe Guru. He offers the head of the slanderer on his sword.) This is also a teaching. Sakat sang naa keejeeay dooro jaa-ee-ai bhaag." These people are not worth listening, seeing, and being with because they are initially creating a doubt on the Guru.

"I have no problem. Life is simple. I'm not willing to make my life complicated. I shall read Rag Mala as it is. I shall accept Siri Guru Granth as my Guru and the Guru for me and my children as it is. It shall never ever be a holy book to me. It shall be a living Guru to me. It is not an Atma to me. It is a Para Par Param Atma to me. I shall live for it and if time asks me, I'll die for it. I'm born out of it, and I also know how to merge in it. I respect it very well. In this Guru I dwell. Nobody can take it away from me. " Yogi Bhajan.

AKJ.ORG and Dasam Granth Sahib Ji / Ragi Darshan Singh

Unfortunately some of the AKJ think different to the founder of their sect, Bhai Randhir Singh, who firmly believed in the Dasam Granth Sahib Ji. Some of the AKJ are following Ragi Darshan Singh. Darshan Singh has picked up the arguments of Shamsher Singh Ashok, who copied Teja Singh Bhasauria. Darshan Singh even questions the ardas, the same theory of Babu Teja Singh. For some reason these people are vent on redefining Sikhism. Bhai Randhir Singh quotes heavly from Dasam Granth in his writings. Today various "scholars" to distance themselves as much as possible from the Dasam Granth, to avoid "Hindusim"and Indian cultural symbolism, and in the process re-intepret the maryada. Most Sikhs agree that Darshan Singh should be excommunicated from the Panth.
AKJ.org has recently issued a statement on their web forum clarifying their position on the Sri Dasam Granth. However their statement is not very clear and is in fact contradicted by various AKJ leaders who have taken a pro Dasam Granth Stance in 2008. In their statement it states that they speak for AKJ worldwide but this is incorrect as the name of AKJ is being tarnished by AKJ.org which is now creating confusionThe statements states that they have chosen not publicize the issue of Sri Dasam Granth and that “many have raised what seem to be plausible doubts about some parts of The Dasam Granth that, they say, are not the Rachanaa of our Guru Saheb”. This misleading statement confirms that their own faith has been shattered by some anti Dasam Granth proponents. So they seem to disagree with the latest Hukumnama directive on the Sri Dasam Granth which puts their own credibility in doubt. They also state “We are eager to see the researchers prove the facts, and whatever the facts turn out to be, and are agreeable to Khaalsaa Panth, Akhand Keertanee Jathaa will abide by the decisions of Khaalsaa Panth”. Unfortunately this rhetoric has put the AKJ in untenable position. They are not happy with the position taken by the Akal Takht. Especially in light of the fact that the prakash of the Sri Dasam Granth used to take place at the Akal Takht until the 1940’s when it was dislodged by some fanatics. They are not happy with the position taken by Takhts Patna Sahib and Hazur Sahib where prakash of Sri Dasam Granth takes place. Their publication is more worrying especially when some members of the AKJ leadership have come out with a pro Dasam Granth stance in 2008.1) In the Takht Damdama Sahib Conclave “a befitting reply to anti Dasam Granth was given by Bhai Mohkam Singh Ludhiana (Akhand Kirtani Jatha) - Bhai Sahib stated that it is shameful for ragi Darshan Singh to allege that if we believe in Dasam Bani, then we do not respect Guru Granth Sahib Ji. He countered, that in 1978 Singhs from the AkhandKirtani Jatha and the Damdami Taksal sacrificed their lives for the sanctity of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, and they were ready to do that again if the need arises. He asked ragi Darshan Singh and his missionaries if they could show a single sacrifice they had made for the sanctity of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji”. So the recent statement is contradictory to the words of Bhai Mokham Singh. In Resolutions Passed at this conclave at Takht Sri Damdama Sahib against Ragi Darshan Singh it was signed by the AKJ.2) The AKJ refused permission for Ragi Darshan Singh to do Kirtan in January 2008.Jathedar Jagjit Singh Gaba and Ranbir Singh Jaura, President and Secretary respectively of Gurudwara Guru Tegh Bahadur Committee, Jalandhar refuted Prof Darshan Singh for using derogatory language against Guru Gobind Singh and his bani and refused him to perform kirtan at the Gurudwara on maghi day.
In light of the positive stance taken by several members of the AKJ it appears that the new stance by AKJ.org which they “state is the AKJ worldwide stance” is either misguided or that they have actually done a u turn like Ragi Darshan Singh himself. See http://www.sridasamgranth.org/ for the Akj.org statement available to read on the above website.
Also see:

Coming In Punjabi soon

Due to the overwelming reception of this humble offering on this blog. A Guru Da Sikh has voluntered to do the Seva of translating this blog into Punjabi. Many thanks Bhai Sahib Ji.

Rag Mala - The Panch Shabad

Over the years I have been graced with having the darshan of many extant manuscripts of Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Dasam Granth Sahib Ji, and Sarbloh Granth Sahib Ji.

For the benefit of my brothers who doubt the authenticity of the Rag Mala in Adi Guru Granth Sahib. I will as a humble offering to the readers, provide photographic evidence of those Birs of Guru Ji, that are historical, been signed (Daskhat) of the Gurus etc. Some of the copies that were examined by Giani Gurditt Singh, I have also had the opportunity to see. Those findings will also be presented.

Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji, is Nam. It is the true mystical vibration of God. Ik Oankar can be interpreted to mean that Out of the One comes Five sounds or Panch Shabad. Many AKJ's say that Rag Mala has no Ustat of Akal Purukh in it. They are wrong.

The Rag Mala begins Raga Ik Sang Panch Barangam.

There is One Raga with Five wives. This needs to be thought of poetically, not literally as many fanatical people do. There is One God, One essence, One Raga. This Raga has five wives. The Panch Shabad. The five primal sounds that vibrate in the Dasam Dvar. That are talked about again and again in Gurbani, see Dakhni Oankar.

The Ragas then branch out to form a Guladasta, a garland from the primal vibration of the five sounds. This is Raga Mala.

Beej Mantra - Ik Oankar - The Seed.
Mool Mantra - Ik Oankar - Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach - The root.
Madh Mantra - the Japji Sahib - The trunk.
Guru Granth Sahib - The branches.
Rag Mala - The flowers.
Think of a tree with blossoms in three dimensions, and visualise it. This is the same way the Adi Guru Granth Sahib is ordered.
The Dakhni Oankar contains many references to God being the Oneness or the One. The Panch shabad also find amny references in the Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji. That from the Oneness of God came the five primal vibrations of Sound.
Raga Ik Sang Panch Barangam.
A brother has emailed the following to share with the Sangat:
There are Raags in certion sections of Guru Granth Sahib jee (mukh and raag parkara sections) which are not in the Raag mala, these include raag mali gaura and Raag Jaijaiwanti. I believe the reason these raags are not in Raag mala is because they are not apart of hindustani Sangeet. mali Gaura came from Arab Desh and Jaijaiwanti for example is the creation of Guru Tegh bahadur jee (this raag cant be apart of raag mala anyway because it was not composed at Guru Arjan dev jees time). It would be impossible for mali Gaura to be in Raag mala because it does not belong to the family tree of the Raag mala (the 6 thaats of raag mala). Its like you making your family tree, you wont have my name in there because we have no blood relation. The raags in Raag mala which are not in the mukh guru granth Sahib (31) or Raag parkar (31 such as Tilang kafi, gauri chiti, Gauri manj etc) belong to the 6 thaat raags. It is possible to do kirtan if the raag belongs to the thaat. For example Shankara (also in raag mala) belongs to Raag bilawal and alot of bandishs and compositions which Raagis teach from Shankara will be from shabads in Raag bilawal. (people such as Principle Dyal Singh who have published books prove this and have compositions passed down through generations) This relation of the thaat that a raag belongs to is important when doing kirtan. Some writers even say that Raag mala is the first documentation of Gurmat Sangeet. I think its Dr Taran Singh jee who writes on the atamic importance of Raag mala. you will find Akjs say Raag mala has nothing to do with the atama. However this is incorrect. Raag bilawal for example is about happiness. The happiness is in relation to once meeting the guru all sorrows pain etc are/have been taken away......for example look at the shabad in Raag bilawal..... shant payee gur satgur poori sukh oopjai vajai anhad toori Rahaoo. Taap paap santap bindash, har simrat kilvikh sabh nasi .......also...... Rog gaiya prabh aap gvaya. Jaijaivanti raag is a khusi raag, however the shabads are all about death, the khusi is in relation to meeting to the guru, then Death can only be khushi and not ghami. Jaijaivanti represents this concept, its not simply a raag name, there is a deeper concept behind the name. Unfortunantly people who dont have any knowledge of raags have not and seem not willing to grasp this knowledge. Its often claimed raag mala does end in any pauri with nanak (therefore it cant be gurubani), however there are many shabads in Jap jee sahib and Guru granth sahib jee maharaj which dont end with nanak, will AKjs take them out? Also shabads in the Dasam granth are the same. In Sri Raag its written that Sri Raag is the mukh raag (raaga vich Sri Raag hai) however in Raag mala its written bairoo. The reason Sant Singh maskeen jee gave was that both are raags are accepted in different areas of India as being the mukh raag. Its like there are 4/5 ways which raag basant is claimed to be sung (the following Thaats are claimed: bilawal, poorvi, Kalyan and marva). Akjs claim Alam wrote the Raag mala. However in Bhai Vir Singh jes Shabad Kosh you will see a comparision of the Raag mala written by Guru Sahiban and Alam,. They are obviously different and AKJs are lying as normal. Finally AKJs claim prof Sahib Singh jee said raag mala is not bani. This is incorrect, he never said its not bani, he simply said it does not follow gurbani viakaran principles. I accept this aswell, however that does not mean its not gurbani. Further Prof Sahib Singh in his book adi bir bari clearly writes which writings he felt is not Gurbani (such as mira bhai's writings). However Prof Sahib Singh jee does not include Raag mala as being bani which he questioned as being guru sahibs bani.

Keski

S. Kapur Singh ICS states: "Bhai Randhir Singh and his admirers claim and assert that five K's obligatory for an Amritdhari Sikh, a Singh, include a Keski, i.e., a short turban for men and women, as a must and one of the other K's, Kangha (comb) is not one of the five Do's...It is wholly arbitrary and schismatic...and thus an act of sabotage against the solidarity and monolithicism of the Khalsa."
Das will be providing the whole article for the readers shortly.
The Jatha regards the following to be true:

i. Rahit Naama of Bhai Chaupa Singh Ji contains the following couplet regarding 'rahits':
ਕਛ ਕੜਾ ਕਿਰਪਾਨ ਕੰਘਾ ਕੇਸਕੀ, ਇਹ ਪੰਜ ਕਕਾਰੀ ਰਹਿਤ ਧਾਰੇ ਸਿਖ ਸੋਈ ।
Kachh, Kada, Kirpan, Kangha, Keski. Eh Panj Kakaari Rahit Dhaarey Sikh Soyee.
To be a Sikh, one must observe five rahits of wearing five Sikh symbols beginning with 'K': Kachh, Kada, Kirpan, Kangha, and Keski. (Those Sikhs not believing in keski have wrongfully broken the word Keski in this couplet into two words, Kes and Ki, indicating it to mean "the rahit of keshas.")

Tradition regards this to be true:

ਕਛ ਕੜਾ ਕਿਰਪਾਨ ਕੰਘਾ ਕੇਸ, ਕੀ ਇਹ ਪੰਜ ਕਕਾਰੀ ਰਹਿਤ ਧਾਰੇ ਸਿਖ ਸੋਈ ।
Kachh, Kara, Kirpan, Kangha, Kesh, ki Eh Panj Kakaari Rahit Dhaarey Sikh Soyee.

The Kaccha, Kara, Kirpan, Kangha and Kesh are the Five Kakkars to be worn by a Sikh with discipline.

A humble request to readers

Do you know anything about the history of the AKJ, Panch Khand, AKJ practices. Have you any photographs of old copies of Adi Guru Granth Sahib? Would you like to contribute to this blog? I would be really grateful if there is any information or internet link you could send me. My email is kamalroop_singh@hotmail.com.

All the best.

Das Kamalroop Singh

The modification of Gurbani: A traditional account versus the AKJ Bhasauria view


In the Sikh tradition Gurbani is perfection on this earth. It is considered to be God, and the Adi Guru Granth Sahib seen as being One with God. That the Guru is Bani and the Bani is Guru. That Ik Oankar, the word is the formlessness of God, the original Nam, or True-Identity in the known and unknown universe.



Therefore in Sikh tradition to modify Gurbani is any way, is a great sacreligious act. In many ways akin to the destruction of the Sri Darbar Sahib, the Golden Temple, by Massa Ranghar. In fact in Sikh history, Ram Rai was not granted the audience of his father after modifying, the word Musalman, to Baiman, in order to please the Emperor Aurangzeb.



Everyday Sikhs recite that the Guru Granth Sahib is the body of the Guru. Therefore in this regard how can any Sikh legitimise the modification of any Gurbani? In tradition this is seen as the ultimate disregard for the tradition of the Panth, and of the Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji.





In the nitnem two times a day Sikhs read the Chaupai Sahib of the Tenth Master, Guru Gobind Singh. Around 1919 after the Panch Khand, under the leadership of Teja Singh Bhasauria, one of the Panj Pyaras of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, managed to get one of his friends into the Head Granthi position at Sri Darbar Sahib, Amritsar. The Chaupai sahib was then reduced in size. In comparison this would be the same as reading upto Salok in JapJi Sahib and finishing there. The line kripa kare ham par jag mata was not read, as it was believed by the AKJ Panch Khand that this was the worship of the Mother Goddess, Durga.


In Jaap Sahib of Guru Gobind Singh, we find a line Namo Lokh Mata. Therefore both male and female names have been used for God by the Guru. Also by not completing a full recitation of a bani, its benefit cannot be recieved. Therefore this was a deliberate ploy to disable the Sikhs. The rahiras was modified many times in the rule of the British, please see Gurbani Path Darpan, Sant Baba Gurbachan Singh Bhinderawale. Baba Ji explains within this book, what the full rahiras and Chaupai Sahib was.


In the Dasam Granth Nirne of 1919 by the son of Babu Teja Singh, we find the first reference to the idea that Chaupai should be cut down. Before this time this is no reference in any book, or Granth. Therefore in order for Babu Teja Singh to clear Sikhism of "Hindu" elements, he made many blunders, that broke the very foundation of traditional Sikhi. There are no handwritten copies of Chaupai Sahib in any manuscript that are incomplete. It is very sad for traditional Sikhs that the writings of Guru Gobind Singh, are being printed incomplete.











When reciting Gurbani a Sikh made a mistake in pronounciation, cutting a long story short, the Guru said he felt pain because of this. Therefore from a Sikh orthodox perspective how much pain would the Guru feel, when bani is printed incomplete. As well as not recited completely. The same applies for Ardas, and Raga Mala. Bani Hai Guru Guru Hai Bani.


For this reason Babu Teja Singh and Panch Khand were unceremoniously excommunicated from the Guru Khalsa Panth. Here is a copy of the original Hukamnama:




The Panth is still following an edict that was started by Teja Singh who was later excommunicated. The Panth should go back to read all of gurbani and giving gurbani the respect it deserves. Here is the portion of gurbani that is removed:

ਕ੍ਰਿਪਾ ਕਰੀ ਹਮ ਪਰ ਜਗਮਾਤਾ ॥ ਗ੍ਰੰਥ ਕਰਾ ਪੂਰਨ ਸੁਭ ਰਾਤਾ ॥

The Mother of the world has been kind towards me and I have completed the book this auspicious night;

ਕਿਲਬਿਖ ਸਕਲ ਦੇਹ ਕੋ ਹਰਤਾ ॥ ਦੁਸ਼ਟ ਦੋਖਿਯਨ ਕੋ ਛੈ ਕਰਤਾ ॥੪੦੨

The Lord is the destroyer of all the sins of the body and all the malicious and wicked persons.402.ਸ੍ਰੀ ਅਸਿਧੁਜ ਜਬ ਭਏ ਦਯਾਲਾ ॥ ਪੂਰਨ ਕਰਾ ਗ੍ਰੰਥ ਤਤਕਾਲਾ ॥

When Mahakal became kind, He immediately caused me to complete this book;

ਮਨ ਬਾਂਛਤ ਫਲ ਪਾਵੈ ਸੋਈ ॥ ਦੂਖ ਨ ਤਿਸੈ ਬਿਆਪਤ ਕੋਈ ॥੪੦੩

He will obtain the fruit desired by the mind (who will read or listen to this book) and no suffering will occur to him.403.

ਅੜਿੱਲ॥ ARRIL

ਸੁਨੈ ਗੁੰਗ ਜੋ ਯਾਹਿ ਸੁ ਰਸਨਾ ਪਾਵਈ ॥

ਸੁਨੈ ਮੂੜ੍ਹ ਚਿਤ ਲਾਇ ਚਤੁਰਤਾ ਆਵਈ ॥

The dumb, who will listen to it, will be blessed with the tongue to speak; the fool, who will listen to it attentively, will get wisdom;

ਦੂਖ ਦਰਦ ਭੌ ਨਿਕਟ ਨ ਤਿਨ ਨਰ ਕੇ ਰਹੈ ॥ ਹੋ ਜੋ ਯਾਕੀ ਏਕ ਬਾਰ ਚੌਪਈ ਕੋ ਕਹੈ ॥੪੦੪॥

That person will be absolved of suffering, pain or fear, who will even once recite this Chaupai-prayer.404.

ਚੌਪਈ ॥CHAUPAI

ਸੰਬਤ ਸੱਤ੍ਰਹ ਸਹਸ ਭਣਿੱਜੈ ॥

ਅਰਧ ਸਹਸ ਫੁਨਿ ਤੀਨਿ ਕਹਿੱਜੈ ॥

It was Bikrami Samvat 1753;

ਭਾਦ੍ਰਵ ਸੁਦੀ ਅਸ਼ਟਮੀ ਰਵਿ ਵਾਰਾ ॥

ਤੀਰ ਸਤੁੱਦ੍ਰਵ ਗ੍ਰੰਥ ਸੁਧਾਰਾ ॥੪੦੫॥

This book was competed on the banks of Sutlej on Sunday, the eighth Sudi of the month of Bhadon.

Listen to the following video for further clarification:




Some points regarding the Akhand Kirtani Sect and Namdhari Sect


1. The Namdharis have a modification of the 5 K's, the Kirpan is reduced to a small symbolic Kirpan on the Kangha. In comparison the AKJ modify the Keski to a new K. However the Namdharis have a symbolic Kirpan, and lack a real Kirpan. While members of the AKJ have all 5 K's including Kesh, but believe the turban (Keski) to be a K, rather than Kesh.

2. The Namdharis accept the Adi Guru Granth Sahib as a legitimate Sikh scripture, but not as a Guru. The AKJ accept the Adi Guru Granth Sahib as Guru, but believe not all of the scripture is authentic (raga mala).

3. The Namdharis believe in the authenticity of the Ugradanti bani. So did the founding father of the AKJ, Bhai Sahib Sant Randhir Singh Ji. Incidently so do the Nihangs.

4. The Namdharis believe in Bibek (ritualistic spiritual hygiene) from non- Namdharis. This is also the case for the strictest in the AKJ sect, while most AKJ's will eat from most other Khalsa amritdhari Sikhs. Incidently some Nihangs also practice this. This involves not eating of the hands from a person who serves and eats meat and drinks alcohol. Or in circumstances that their food may not be in sucham as it will be prepared in the same place where meat and alcohol is being made or drunk. This also applies to eating from restraunts where meat is being made.

5. The Namdharis, like the Radha-Soami's believe that they have the Nam from the Guru. This is of course exclusive to their sect. This is the same for the AKJ.

6. The Namdharis, AKJ, are staunch vegetarians. Incidently Damdami Taksal, Nirmalla, Radha-Soami's, as well as most other Hindu sects, are strict vegetarians.
7. The AKJ may have copied the breath meditation technique from Namdharis who had been doing it for a hundred years previously. Namdharis were noted by the British observers as doing Naam Simran with a specific cyclical method of Naam Simran and breathing. The records state this involved emphasis on the latter half of Vah-i-guru causing the r sound to roll, and this created the well-known kuks which is why they were called Kukay. The AKJ are renowned for doing this.
8. Namdharis perform Kirtan with traditional instruments, and in Rag measures. The AKJ perform Kirtan in Punjabi folk geet style.

The Islamic Sufi Influence on AKJ Simran

The method used in the Panch Khand and AKJ around the practice of Vahiguroo repitition, is peculiar to them alone. In Gurmantar Prabodh the founder of the AKJ-Panch Khand, Babu Teja Singh gives his reasoning behind this method.

Here we offer a comparison with Sufi technqiues and Tantric techniques found in India, and Pakistan. This technique is unique only to the AKJ sect, and not the rest of the Sikh Panth.






Listen to the below Kirtan of the Sikhs of the AKJ at around 1 minute into the clip:

http://www.sikh-heritage.co.uk/movements/Akhand%20Keertan/Akhand%20KJatha.htm

It was in this way that Teja Singh Bhasauria suceeded in converting Punjabi Muslims to become part of the AKJ.

This technique was also employed by the cult leader OSHO. Apparently he learnt the technique from the Sufi orders and added a Tantric twist to it, typical of his style. Please listen to the clip below:

http://69.24.65.182/downloads/samples/Chakra%20Breathing/t1.mp3

The AKJ and the Sikh Rahit Maryada

The Akhand Kirtan Jatha, pride themselves on having what they believe is a pristine or Tat Gurmat Marayada. Though this is positive for the beliefs of the members of the AKJ , this can turn into a critique of other Sikh groups. This ocassinally finds itself into web forums, but is usually said in dialogue. Therefore it is only just to analyse if the AKJ maryada fits that of the Khalsa Panth, in the form of the Sikh Rahit Maryada of the supreme Akal Takht Sahib.

The Sikh Rahit Maryada is the accepted document for the whole Sikh Panth. This discussion is aimed at comparing the AKJ practices with those in the Sikh Rahit Maryada, and if the Jatha fall in line with the SRM.

Sikh Reht Maryada
Section Six
CHAPPTER XIII

Panthic Rehni (Facets of Corporate Sikh Life):

I. The Keshas (unshorn hair), II. The Kirpan {sheathed sword} (The length of the sword to be worn is not prescribed., III. The Kachhehra (The Kachhehra (drawers like garment) may be made from any cloth, but its legs should not reach down to below the shins.),IV. The Kanga (comb),V. The Karha {steel bracelet} (The Karha should be of pure steel.)
The undermentioned four transgressions (tabooed practices) must be avoided
1. Dishonouring the hair;2. Eating the meat of an animal slaughtered the Muslim way; 3. Cohabiting with a person other than one's spouse;4. Using tobacco.


The Akhand Kirtan Jatha, gives a small underturban, the KESKI as a K. As well as giving the injunction that any meat is a transgression. Therefore we must question if the AKJ being exclusive, with their own extra ammendments to the maryada.

Sikh Reht Maryada
THE CODE OF SIKH CONDUCT AND CONVENTIONS
Section Four
CHAPTER X
t. For a Sikh, there is no restriction or requirement as to dress except that he must wear Kachhehra (A drawer type garment fastened by a fitted string round the waist, very often worn as an underwear.) and turban. A Sikh woman may or may not tie turban.
This contradicts the AKJ practice of all members having to wear turbans.

THE CODE OF SIKH CONDUCT AND CONVENTIONS
CHAPTER V
Kirtan (Devotional Hymns Singing by a Group or an Indvidual) Article VI a) Only a Sikh may perform Kirtan in a congregation. b) Kirtan means singing the scriptural compositions in traditional musical measures. c) In the congragation, Kirtan only of Gurbani (Guru Granth's or Guru Gobind Singh's hymns) and, for its elaboration, of the compositions of Bhai Gurdas and Bhai Nand Lal, may be performed. d) It is improper, while singing hymns to rhythmic folk tunes or to traditional musical measures, or in team singing, to induct into them improvised and extraneous refrains. Only a line from the hymn should be made a refrain.
The AKJ only allow Amritdhari Sikhs to perform Kirtan. They do not sing Kirtan in the traditional measures. They do not state clearly that they believe in the hymns of Guru Gobind Singh, even though Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji did not agree the views of Babu Teja Singh on the Dasam Granth. Some, like Mohinder Singh SDO do not believe in the writings of Bhai Gurdas. They regularly use improvised and extraneous refrains from other hymns in the Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
a. The reading of the whole Guru Granth Sahib (intermittent or non-stop) may be concluded with the reading of Mundawani or the Rag Mala according to the convention traditionally observed at the concerned place. (Since there is a difference of opinion within the Panth on this issue, nobody should dare to write or print a copy of the Guru Granth Sahib excluding the Rag Mala). Thereafter, after reciting the Anand Sahib, the Ardas of the conclusion of the reading should be offered and the sacred pudding (Karhah Prashad) distributed.
Some members of the AKJ unfortunately in the past removed the Rag Mala from the Adi Guru Granth Sahib, normally kept in private places. See the manuscripts written by Sobha Singh, and Teja Singh Bhasauria. This is against the injunctions above, and would case a great deal of injury to the sentiments of most Sikhs. The Dam Dami Taksal in India regular check the various printed versions of the Adi Guru Granth Sahib to make sure this practice does not continue.
Sikh Reht Maryada
SIKH CODE OF CONDUCT AND CONVENTIONS
Section One

CHAPTER 1The Definition of Sikh : Article IAny human being who faithfully believes ini. One Immortal Being, ii. Ten Gurus, from Guru Nanak Sahib to Guru Gobind Singh Sahib,iii. The Guru Granth Sahib, iv. The utterances and teachings of the ten Gurus and
v. the baptism bequeathed by the tenth Guru, and who does not owe allegiance to any other religion, is a Sikh
It seems on first glance that the AKJ follow the above. Unfortunately this is not the case. As the AKJ regularly rebaptise people, who have not been intiated in the AKJ. Rebaptism can only occur if somebody has commited a major aberration. They rebaptise as they believe the amrit by other organisation is devoid of spiritual energy or Nam Rasa. Therefore does the AKJ not believe in the baptism bequeathed by the tenth Guru?
o. After this the five beloved ones, all together in chorus communicating the name of Waheguru to all who have been administered the ambrosial baptism, recite to them the Mul Mantar (basic creed, seminal chant) and make them repeat it aloud :
Here the AKJ hug the initiate the person close, in a ritual to impart the name of God, Vahiguru. Again this is not in line with the Sikh Rahit Maryada document. This method is also found in Sufism and Tantra cults in India. Hence it is against Gurmat. As the Guru says in the closing of the Anand Sahib: hearing the name one becomes Pure.
The AKJ have argued that they believe in the Sikh Rahit Maryada. The proof will be when Kesh is given as a Kakkar, and people stop being re-baptised, by the AKJ. This will be a truely Panthic move by the AKJ.

A Statement

http://www.panthic.org/news/131/ARTICLE/4518/2008-11-14.html

I am not questioning your good intentions surrounding the editorial article. However, I would like make a categorical denial of claims in your editorial that pertain to me. Firstly, I am not a follower of Niddar Singh. Secondly, I do not believe in Snatanism. My PHD involves the study of the manuscripts of the Dasam Granth as well as the siginificance of the Dasam Granth to the Khalsa. As previously stated by me on your website:
I do not believe that Sikhi is Snatan. Sikhi is Sikhi. Khalsa is the Third Panth, the third way. The Khalsa belongs to the Guru, and the Guru to the Khalsa. The Khalsa is not an off-shoot of any other movement. It became manifest by the order of Akal . I would ask you to publish this reply so that your readers are aware of facts that are personal to me.
Kamalroop Singh